📱 CLICK HERE TO ORDER DELIVERY & TAKE-OUT

Cindy's Pizzas
Cindy's Pizzas
  • Home
  • Menu
  • About
  • Catering
  • Wholesale
  • Contact
  • More
    • Home
    • Menu
    • About
    • Catering
    • Wholesale
    • Contact
ORDER NOW
  • Home
  • Menu
  • About
  • Catering
  • Wholesale
  • Contact
ORDER NOW

Award-Winning Brick Oven Pizza in Stillwater

Award-Winning Brick Oven Pizza in StillwaterAward-Winning Brick Oven Pizza in StillwaterAward-Winning Brick Oven Pizza in Stillwater

Locally owned, family-operated, and serving Stillwater with hand-stretched dough and homemade sauce since 2012. 

See Our Menu

Award-Winning Brick Oven Pizza in Stillwater

Award-Winning Brick Oven Pizza in StillwaterAward-Winning Brick Oven Pizza in StillwaterAward-Winning Brick Oven Pizza in Stillwater

Locally owned, family-operated, and serving Stillwater with hand-stretched dough and homemade sauce since 2012. 

See Our Menu

🥇 SCOVIE SAUCE AWARD WINNER

👩‍🍳 WOMAN-OWNED BUSINESS

WHERE THE LOCALS EAT

Made the Right Way. No Shortcuts.

We've been making New York-style pizza in Stillwater, OK since 2012 and today we're one of the only privately-owned pizza restaurants in Stillwater. Every pizza starts with dough we hand-stretch using traditional techniques before they're topped with a sauce that's won international recognition at the Scovie Awards.

ABOUT CINDY'S

Loved In Stillwater

What We're Known For

NY-STYLE PIZZAS

NY-STYLE PIZZAS

NY-STYLE PIZZAS

TAKE & BAKE

NY-STYLE PIZZAS

NY-STYLE PIZZAS

CHEESECAKE

NY-STYLE PIZZAS

CHEESECAKE

 New pizza toppings and seasonal specials rotate regularly. 

View Full Menu



Hot Pizza, Ready When You Are

Our Take & Bake pizzas are fully assembled in-house with fresh toppings, house-made sauce, ready for your home oven whenever you are. Perfect for family dinners, game nights, and stocking the freezer. We also sell in bulk to local businesses, organizations, and fundraisers. 


Also available: award-winning sauces & fresh-frozen dough balls for baking at home. 

ORDER TAKE & BAKE

Let Cindy's Cater Your Next Event

Catering for Any Occasion

Catering for Any Occasion

Catering for Any Occasion

Brick oven pizzas, Take & Bakes, and cheesecake for birthdays, office lunches, and game days. Call ahead and we'll handle the rest. 

Take & Bake Fundraisers

Catering for Any Occasion

Catering for Any Occasion

 Partner with us on a Take & Bake pizza fundraiser for your school, team, or organization. Reach out to get started. 

LEARN ABOUT CATERING

Interested in wholesale?

We handle wholesale inquiries directly. Reach out by phone to discuss quantities, pricing, and delivery options within Stillwater.

Call (405) 780-5123
  • Order
  • Menu
  • About
  • Catering
  • Wholesale
  • Contact

Cindy's Pizza | Award-Winning Pizza in Stillwater

Hours

Tue–Sat 4:00–8:00 PM · Sun–Mon Closed


Visit Us

3507 S. Husband St., Stillwater, OK 74074

405-780-5123


© 2026 Cindy's Pizzas. All Rights Reserved.

This website uses cookies.

We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.

Accept